In response to some recent reviews, I feel compelled to write a post about all the things I wish every Teachers Pay Teachers patron knew about giving feedback.
Before I get into the tips though, I want to say that I truly appreciate ALL of the feedback I receive --whether it be good or bad--because that means that another teacher somewhere in the world took a chance on something I created to use in their own classroom. This means that another teacher voted with their wallet and said, "I value the teaching profession and feel that teachers should be compensated for their creativity and after-hours work just like any other profession." This means that another teacher decided to "shop small" and support a fellow teacher rather than a big box educational textbook company. For that, I want to say THANK YOU from the bottom of my heart. It blows me away to think about what an impact Teachers Pay Teachers is making in the educational community.
As a precursor to these tips, trick, and etiquette rules, here are a few things to consider. Teachers Pay Teachers is made up of a community of teachers, and your feedback goes directly to their inbox. We are real teachers who get your feedback sent directly to our email and phone app. There's nothing more nerve-wracking than seeing a little green "feedback" notification pop up on my phone. I read EVERY. SINGLE. ONE. On other sites that are feedback driven such as Amazon, there's somewhat of a disconnect between the inventor of the item or author of the book that you are reviewing. On those sites, it seems unlikely that the person who poured their heart and soul into their work will ever see your opinion of their product. Teachers Pay Teachers is different. By cutting out educational publishing companies (and their markups), you get a direct link to the TEACHER that designed the lesson you are buying. This means that the TEACHER who spent hours and hours of afterschool time designing a lesson to help you in your classroom will be the one reading your feedback.
That said, here are a few tips, tricks, and etiquette rules to consider the next time you leave feedback.
1. Think about your purpose for leaving feedback.
Purpose 1: To get TpT credit so that you can cash in for future resources. Some people still don't know this trick, but it's super easy to build up your points and get other resources for free! Simply go to "My Purchases" then click on the "provide feedback." When you go to check out again, you just apply those credits to your total.
Purpose 2: To contact the teacher who designed this lesson for various reasons. Many of the people who leave me feedback actually just want to ask me something, and they don't know another way of contacting me. The way TpT is set up, teacher authors on this site don't have access to teacher emails or ways of contacting buyers. I can't tell you how many times I have wished that I could reach out to a buyer and let them know something important about an update to a lesson. I know that my buyers feel the same. I try to remember to leave my email in each product, but when a teacher is in a hurry, this might be hard to look up. However, there is a better way to contacting teacher authors when you need a typo fixed or have a question. If you go to the "my purchases" that I showed you above, you can click on the Q&A tab. This too is a direct way to contact sellers if you don't have their email. We are notified immediately with the question but can respond only once. If you know this question will take multiple back-and-forth responses, then please leave your email.
As I mentioned above, it's always nerve-wracking to get the feedback notification, but something that is 10x more nerve-wracking is the Q&A notification because this most likely means that a teacher who purchased my lesson is having problems with something. This is the absolute worst because I know the feeling of thinking you have everything prepared for a day's lesson only to find out too late that something isn't working. I really hate it when this happens, but I'm always so appreciative when someone contacts me via Q&A before leaving feedback. I and most sellers I know respond very quickly to these because we want everything to be correct for you.
An example of nonhelpful feedback:
This is the first feedback I received on a unit that literally took me 100+ hours to create. I worked two to five hours EVERY DAY after school for two months on this single novel guide. It's quality work and highly engaging. My students loved it, and so did hers. Yet, now this unit's one-and-only feedback (so far) is a 3.8 which means that other teachers might skim right past it search because they would need to click it to see that the rating doesn't match what this teacher thought about my work. If this teacher would have listed details (or better yet, emailed me first), then I would have been happy to change anything that she needed. I strive to make sure every teacher that supports my store is completely happy with their purchase. I take all constructive feedback into account and constantly improve my resources.
An example of helpful feedback:
As you can see in this next example, this teacher told me and other teachers exactly what she found helpful and explained why she marked me down for thoroughness. Sure, she could have asked me for a rubric before giving feedback, but I know that most teachers don't have to time to wait or to ask for something they needed and expected to have, and I'm ok with that. I would much rather see feedback like this than the vague example above.
2. If a teacher uses your feedback to improve the lesson, consider changing your feedback to reflect the newly updated resource.
This is asking for a lot since you already took the time to leave one review, but it's just something to consider and a little trick that some people don't know about. For example, on the feedback below, this teacher was absolutely correct. Since this feedback, I've added 5 more devices and keep adding more.
She is able to get to her new files by going to the "my purchase" and seeing that the file has been updated. This is what it will look like:
If you never knew about this trick, then you are in for a treat! Depending on what you have purchased, it can be like Christmas finding all kinds of newly added material to things you already own!!
If you feel so inclined to revise your review based on newly added material, you can go back to "my purchases," click on the resource, then find your review and click "edit"
This has never personally happened to me, but I see it happen to my teacher author friends and just shake my head. I just don't get why someone would go out of their way to leave negative feedback on something FREE that another teacher designed and gave as a gift so that their life would be a little easier. First off, it's kind of hard to even get to the spot where you leave feedback for free times. You have to go to "My Purchases" like I showed you above, but then you have to find the "free" tab and go from there. Secondly, you don't get any credits for leaving feedback on free items. Thirdly, it takes all of two minutes to search for a free lesson, download, skim it, and decide if it's worth using or not. If you don't like it, move on to a different lesson; don't leave feedback. If you do like it, then show your appreciation for a FREE gift by leaving all A's.
4. Don't take your "buyer's remorse" out on a fellow teacher.
Ah, the dreaded buyer's remorse; it happens to us all. You are caught up in the moment, enticed by a sale, or overlook a key description. Buying those Halloween Lularoe leggings comes to mind....
Think about all of the times you have impulsively purchased something that you later regretted. What did you do about it? Did you try to get your money back even though you had already used the item? Did you write the proprietor a letter stating all the reasons why you regretted making a purchase? Or, did you simply chalk it up to a few lost dollars and move on? For me, it's the latter. This is how I treat my digital TpT purchases as well. Every time Teachers Pay Teachers has one of their rare sales, I always end up with a cart full of AMAZING clipart and teaching resources for things that I have no desire to create on my own (*cough* Julius Caesar *cough*). Without fail though, there is always something that I purchase that I could have lived without, wasn't what I thought it was, or I just never ended up using. That's ok. I either don't leave feedback, or I leave all A's. It's not their fault that I bought something that I didn't fully read the description on or fully consider the practicality of it fitting into my classroom.
Case in point:
This buyer obviously had vehement buyer's remorse. Sadly, if she would have just downloaded my preview to see pictures of students (and my good-sport husband) wearing the glasses, she could have saved herself $3 and saved me a good cry. This feedback was written over a year ago, but I still cringe just looking at it. Feedback hurts the most when it unfairly criticizes something in which you take the most pride in. For me, this is my creativity. Ouch.
Here is the preview of the lesson that she had such a strong reaction to:
Even though giving feedback earns TpT credits, it's still hard for busy teachers to remember to leave feedback. However, there's NOTHING better than getting a heartfelt review from a peer, so if you can, take the time to leave a review. I mentioned the negative review above that made me cry, but thankfully, far more positive reviews have brought tears to my eyes to make up for it. Teachers are easy to please--give us a pat on the back or a word of praise, and we can run on that positivity for weeks.
Leaving feedback is a way to say "Thank You" to a teacher who spent hours and hours of their time to create something that allowed you to save yours. What were you able to do with those extra hours you weren't searching, brainstorming, and writing for a lesson to use in your classroom? Maybe you actually had a free weekend for once. Maybe you got to spend some extra time with your own children rather than giving all of you to other people's children. Maybe you binge watched Game of Thrones because it's the only thing that is more unpredictable than a day in the life of a teacher. Whatever it is, this is your chance to show your appreciation for something that has helped you.
Feedback like the ones below are my go-to's for when I feeling low or uncreative.
Feedback for my Beowulf Unit . I love this one because I always want to be the type of teacher this person is by being willing to try new things. I never want to get set in my ways; students are always changing, and I want to adapt with them.
Feedback for this project. Not only did I get this teacher's words of praise, but she also let me know what her students thought of it too. I was absolutely blown away by this.
Lastly, I will leave you with my all-time favorite. Maybe it's because I had such a rough start in teaching (that's a story for another day), but knowing that I played a small part in helping out this new English teacher, makes all the extra hours I put in so worth it. I was this teacher nine years ago, and I can't imagine how much less stressful my life would have been if I would have had TpT back then. This is why I do what I do.
Thank you for reading. If you want to follow along with me on this crazy full-time teacher and full-time TpT life, then check out my Instagram @Bsbooklove